PlainAttorney Register file of Sep 29, 2026 · NY Office of Court Administration, via data.ny.gov

Carl A. Benincasa

On the New York attorney register since 2006 · office in Water Mill, NY

PlainAttorney’s reading of the public register file, not a court record.

Registration No.
4393419
Admitted
2006 · Second Department
Status
Due to re‑register
Next registration
Aug 2026

Carl A. Benincasa is due to re‑register on the New York attorney register file of Sep 29, 2026. Admitted in 2006 in the Second Department, with an office in Water Mill, NY; next registration due Aug 2026. The status is the same in all 3 files we hold. The registration was due in Aug 2026 and the register has not recorded it as filed.

What this status means on the register

On the register, “Due to re‑register” means the attorney has a biennial registration falling due or overdue: the rule asks for it within 30 days after the attorney’s birthday in each alternate year, and the record gives the month it is due. The value stays until the register records the filing or marks the registration delinquent, so the month can have passed; by itself it is not a finding.

  1. Due to re‑register unchanged
  2. Due to re‑register unchanged
  3. Due to re‑register the first file we hold

Source: NY Office of Court Administration, attorney registration file (data.ny.gov, dataset eqw2-r5nb), downloaded Sep 29, 2026; the Jul 3, 2026 and Aug 6, 2026 files for the history.

Others who list this employer on the register

The only other attorney who lists The Benincasa Group or one of its other names:

AttorneyAdmittedStatus
Joseph Maxwell Cibellis2025Currently registered

Source: NY Office of Court Administration, attorney registration file (data.ny.gov, dataset eqw2-r5nb), downloaded Sep 29, 2026; employer spellings merged (methodology).

Where this record sits on the register

Carl A. Benincasa studied at St. John’s University School of Law (the register spells it “St. John's University School of Law”). 2,733 of its 15,595 living graduates on the register were admitted in the 2000s, as Carl A. Benincasa was.

Same law school
15,595living graduates; 88.6% registered (current or due), against 87.1% overall
Office in Water Mill, NY
30living registrants

Of the 30 living registrants with an office in Water Mill, NY, 25 were admitted before 2006 and 4 after.

Source: NY Office of Court Administration, attorney registration file (data.ny.gov, dataset eqw2-r5nb), downloaded Sep 29, 2026; living registrants only.

Questions this record leads to

  1. St. John’s University School of Law graduates on the register15,595 living, 88.6% registered.
  2. Attorneys with an office in Water Mill, NY30 living registrants give an office there.
  3. Suffolk County’s registered bar5,823 currently registered, 3.81 per 1,000 residents.
  4. Admitted in 20068,638 people admitted in 2006 are on the register, 2,271 of them through the Second Department.
  5. Every registration that reads “Due to re‑register”47,986 on the register file of Sep 29, 2026, by decade of admission.
  6. What a New York lawyer may chargeThe court rules on fees, retainers and fee disputes, each cited.

How to confirm it officially

For a statement of Carl A. Benincasa’s standing, contact the Attorney Registration Unit of the NY Office of Court Administration (nycourts.gov/attorneys), or ask the Appellate Division, Second Department, which admitted Carl A. Benincasa in 2006. A complaint about this attorney would go to the Second Department’s Grievance Committee for the Tenth Judicial District, which covers Suffolk County, where the register places the office.

This page reads the register file of Sep 29, 2026, and the court system’s own search can be newer; the register shows only the current value, so a suspension that ended before the files we hold, or a censure, leaves no trace here (Appellate Division decisions are published through the court system’s Law Reporting Bureau).

How to check a lawyer, step by step