New York attorney record · Judicial Dept 2
Carl A. Benincasa
St. John'S University School Of Law alumna, admitted to the New York bar in 2006, registered office in Water Mill, NY. This established record's status, address, and registration history come straight from the NY Office of Court Administration.
- 2006
- Admitted
- 20
- Years in bar
- 4393419
- NY reg #
The record in one line
Carl A. Benincasa appears in the New York attorney register with a current status of "Due to reregister within 30 days of birthday", on record since 2006 - an administrative designation rather than discipline, but confirm current standing with the state bar.
- 20 yrs
- since first admission to the bar
- Pending-renewal
- current bar status: "Due to reregister within 30 days of birthday"
- #27 of 30
- by tenure in Water Mill office peers
- Law school
- St. John'S University School Of Law
Data updated August 2026
What this profile tells you
Bar status & tenure
Carl A. Benincasa is registered as bar number 4393419 with the New York bar authority, carrying a current status of "Due to reregister within 30 days of birthday", a routine periodic-renewal reminder, not discipline. Registration is recorded within Judicial Department 2, the appellate division overseeing this attorney's home district.
Practice context & education
Practice address is listed under The Benincasa Group, located in Water Mill, NY (Suffolk County), ZIP 11976. Educational background: St. John's University School of Law (4,306 registered alumni).
State context & due diligence
A "Due to reregister within 30 days of birthday" status falls outside the New York bar's active cohort for now. The breakdown below shows what share of the register that represents.
Tenure among Water Mill, NY office peers
Water Mill, NY carries only 30 NY-registered attorneys with an admission year on file; Carl A. Benincasa is #27 by tenure in that small local set. See the Water Mill attorney directory .
- Local rank
- #27
- City cohort
- 30
- Local percentile
- 87th
- Admitted
- 2006
Nearest tenure peers in Water Mill
- Carlos A. Piovanetti admitted 2007 · 19 yr
- Michael Patrick Sendlenski admitted 2004 · 22 yr
- Judy Poznik admitted 2002 · 24 yr
- Timothy Allan Greensfelder admitted 1998 · 28 yr
How local rank is computed
Rank uses years since NY-bar admission among non-deceased registry rows that list the same office city and state, a local placement, not a statewide claim. Source: NY Office of Court Administration Attorney Registration · as of August 2026. Derived local rank, not published upstream.
How Carl compares to fellow St. John'S University School Of Law alumni
Among the 5,923 St. John'S University School Of Law graduates in the New York register, Carl A. Benincasa is longer-tenured than 59%.
20 years vs. St. John'S University School Of Law alumni
Years since admission - 5,923 NY-registered alumni of this school
20 Top 41% higher than 59% of 5,923 fellow alumni
Each bar is a band; taller bars hold more fellow alumni. The dashed line + filled bar mark this entry. Hover or tap any bar for its full count, share, and where it sits relative to this entry.
Source NY Office of Court Administration, Attorney Registration · August 2026
St. John'S University School Of Law's active-bar rate
Of St. John'S University School Of Law's 4,306 alumni in the New York register, 86.3% currently hold "Currently registered" status, above the statewide average.
The 2006 admission class today
Of the 8,638 attorneys admitted to the New York bar in 2006, 66.6% are still "Currently registered" today, below the statewide average across all admission years.
Professional Details
- Status
- Due to reregister within 30 days of birthday
- Registration Number
- 4393419
- Year Admitted
- 2006 (20 yrs · senior)
- Judicial Department
- 2
- Next Registration
- Aug 2026
Location & Contact
- Company
- The Benincasa Group
- City
- Water Mill, NY
- County
- Suffolk
- ZIP Code
- 11976
- Phone
- (631) 500-9595
Education
Status Distribution Across the New York Bar
Carl A. Benincasa's current status, "Due to reregister within 30 days of birthday", places this record outside the 67.2% of the 432,625-attorney New York register currently marked active.
Full statewide breakdown & source note
Source: NY Office of Court Administration, Attorney Registrations. Status counts reflect the latest reporting cycle. Bar status confirms registration only; it does not imply competence, specialty fit, or freedom from complaints.
Near-tenure St. John'S University School Of Law alumni
Fellow alumni on the NY register whose admission year is closest to 2006 (excluding same-firm colleagues above).
Same admission year (2006), other cities
NY-registered attorneys admitted in 2006 whose listed office city differs from Water Mill, a vintage cohort, not a neighborhood list.
Nationwide attorneys with similar admission year or city registry density
Two non-geo peer axes for Carl A. Benincasa: closest NY bar admission year outside NY, and closest out-of-state office cities by how many NY-registered attorneys they list (~31 here). Distinct from same-firm, fellow-alumni, and same-year other-city strips above.
Similar admission year (~2006)
Counts come from the NY State Office of Court Administration registration extract; peers are not a competence or practice-area ranking.
Verify This Attorney
Verify on NY Courts Attorney SearchNearby Attorneys in Water Mill, NY
Compare credentials side-by-side
Compare Carl A. Benincasa with similar attorneys in Water Mill.
Compare attorneys →Before you rely on this record
Carl A. Benincasa is currently listed as "Due to reregister within 30 days of birthday", treat that as a registration fact to confirm, not a verdict on quality.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where is Carl Benincasa licensed?
Carl Benincasa is licensed to practice law in New York.
When was Carl A. Benincasa admitted to the bar?
Carl A. Benincasa was admitted to the bar in 2006.
Where did Carl A. Benincasa go to law school?
Carl A. Benincasa attended St. John's University School of Law.
What company does Carl A. Benincasa work for?
Carl A. Benincasa is associated with The Benincasa Group in Water Mill, NY.
Is Carl A. Benincasa in good standing?
Not currently, Carl A. Benincasa's listed status is "Due to reregister within 30 days of birthday", not active standing. Confirm current status with the state bar.
Cite this page & disclosure
Sourced from the NY Office of Court Administration, informational only, not legal advice. Full disclosure.
Read our methodology - how this data is sourced, computed, and verified.