Attorney Discipline Records
Most of New York's licensed attorneys never face discipline. But when a lawyer is disbarred, suspended, or resigns while under investigation, that outcome becomes part of the public record. This page compiles those records from the New York State Office of Court Administration attorney-registration database, cross-referenced against Consumer Financial Protection Bureau complaint data (debt-collection, mortgage, and lending disputes are where attorney misconduct most often surfaces). Each entry reflects the bar's formal disposition: a recorded finding, not an allegation. See ourmethodology for how we source and verify every figure.
Consumer Complaint Context (CFPB)
Beyond bar discipline, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau tracks consumer complaints about debt collection, mortgage, and lending issues, common areas where attorney misconduct surfaces.
Top NY Debt Collection Issues
- 1. Attempts to collect debt not owed 19,773
- 2. Written notification about debt 10,490
- 3. False statements or representation 4,464
- 4. Took or threatened to take negative or legal action 4,438
- 5. Communication tactics 3,782
Data through 2026-03-25. Source: CFPB Consumer Complaint Database.
Showing 17,501–17,550 of 21,141 suspended attorneys
| Name | Status |
|---|---|
| Crystal Dawn Shumaker | Suspended, delinquent |
| Robert C. Shuman | Suspended, delinquent |
| Stephanie Shupack | Suspended, delinquent |
| Michael David Shur | Suspended, delinquent |
| Jennifer H. Shurdut | Suspended, delinquent |
| Richard Fischler Shurtz | Suspended, delinquent |
| Alan Mark Shuster | Suspended, delinquent |
| Keren Shuster | Suspended, delinquent |
| Marci Ann Shuster | Suspended, delinquent |
| William Andrew Shutkin | Suspended, delinquent |
| Joanna Hui Si | Suspended, delinquent |
| Twaambo Mwaandu Sibajene | Suspended, delinquent |
| Andrea Therese Sibley | Suspended, delinquent |
| Montgomery Blair Sibley | Suspended, delinquent |
| Anthony Roger Sica | Suspended, delinquent |
| Gary Peter Sica | Suspended, delinquent |
| Paul J. Sica | Suspended, delinquent |
| Robert John Sickinger | Suspended, delinquent |
| Todd Clifford Sicklinger | Suspended, delinquent |
| Mark Siconolfi | Suspended, delinquent |
| Osama Siddique | Suspended, delinquent |
| Mehnaz Siddiqui | Suspended, delinquent |
| Sorin Anne Siddiqui | Suspended, delinquent |
| Lisa Danielle Sidman | Suspended, due to reregister |
| Stanley M. Siede | Suspended, delinquent |
| Allen Howard Siegal | Suspended, delinquent |
| Jennifer Lee Siegal-Miller | Suspended, delinquent |
| Barry Jonathan Siegel | Suspended, delinquent |
| Deanna L. Siegel | Suspended, delinquent |
| Elizabeth Baker Siegel | Suspended, delinquent |
| Ellie O. Siegel | Suspended, delinquent |
| Jeremy Solomon Siegel | Suspended, delinquent |
| Lori F. Siegel | Suspended, delinquent |
| Marc Z. Siegel | Suspended, delinquent |
| Mark Alan Siegel | Suspended, delinquent |
| Robert Paul Siegel | Suspended, delinquent |
| Ronald Stewart Siegel | Suspended, delinquent |
| Resa Jean Siegel Tanner | Suspended, delinquent |
| Lui Sieh | Suspended, delinquent |
| Amanda Leah Siek | Suspended, delinquent |
| Catherine Ann Siemann | Suspended, delinquent |
| Wolfram Reinhard Siemens | Suspended, delinquent |
| John Christopher Siemers | Suspended, delinquent |
| Laura Diane Siemers | Suspended, delinquent |
| Amy Sieminski | Suspended, delinquent |
| Michael Joseph Sieradzki | Suspended, delinquent |
| Steven Solomon Sieratzki | Suspended, delinquent |
| Mara-Lee Ann Sievert | Suspended, delinquent |
| Alexander How Wai Siew | Suspended, delinquent |
| Adam Lee Sifre | Suspended, delinquent |
Disclaimer: This information is sourced from public state bar records. Discipline status reflects the state bar's records at the time of data collection. PlainAttorney does not provide legal advice. Always verify attorney credentials directly with the relevant state bar.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does it mean when an attorney is disbarred?
Disbarment is the most severe disciplinary action a state bar can take. A disbarred attorney has had their license to practice law permanently revoked, typically due to serious ethical violations, criminal conduct, or repeated misconduct. There are currently 2,178 disbarred attorneys in our records.
How many attorneys have discipline records?
PlainAttorney tracks 24,037 attorneys with discipline records, including 2,178 disbarred, 21,141 suspended, and 718 who resigned while facing discipline. This data comes from public state bar records.
Can a disbarred attorney practice law?
No. A disbarred attorney cannot legally practice law. In some states, a disbarred attorney may petition for reinstatement after a waiting period (typically 5-7 years), but reinstatement is not guaranteed and requires demonstrating rehabilitation and fitness to practice.
Where does this discipline data come from?
All discipline data is sourced from public state bar registration records. These are official records maintained by state bar associations and courts. Data is updated quarterly. For the most current status, consult the relevant state bar directly.